I've been waiting to do this comparison, and I have been collecting all of the black and charcoal holos I could find. I'm sure there are more out there :)
Index: Petites Color Fever "Black Diamond"
Middle: OPI (MPJ) "My Private Jet"
Ring: Color Club "Revvolution"
Pinkie: Diamond Cosmetics "Chain Mail Charm"
Now, in terms of darkness, it goes: MPJ, Black Diamond, CHC, and Revv.
In terms of holoness, it's" MPJ, CHC, Revv, and Black Diamond.
I know, I know, you're thinking which one do I like the most?...I love them all but
MPJ is the best overall , not just because its the holo version, and not because its hard to find, but because it delivers exactly what I want...black holo perfection.
I don't believe this is the first version of MPJ, but it makes ME happy, and that's all a girl can ask for ...my next favorite is Diamond Cosmetics "Chain Mail Charm"...this I tell you ladies, is the 2nd best polish for several reasons:
1. It delivers in color, deep dark charcoal, and once its layered over black, gorgeous!!!!
2. It delivers in quality, goes on great, wears well and easy to take off!!
3. It delivers in holo...oh lordie does it deliver, no issues here!!!
4. But the best part is the price...$2.25...you can not beat that with a stick, no way jose!
MPJ may be the King in this court, but Chain Mail Charm is the Queen and we all know behind every strong man, is a stronger woman.
Keep it sweet my queens :)